Listed : $489,900
2026-08-06
37 Fifth Avenue, St. Thomas
2
2
$749,90073 Fifth
2+2 bed•4 bath•2500-3000 sqft
NEW
73 Fifth Avenue
St. Thomas, St. Thomas, ON N5R 4C9
$749,900
Taxes: $3,651/yr
2+2Bedrooms
4Bathrooms
2500-3000Sqft
12 days ago13 days on marketLot 60.08 × 120.79 ft (irregular)MLS®: X13752156Sale
DetachedFreehold
Lot60.08 × 120.79 ft (irregular)
Driveway2
Total parking2
BasementFull, Finished
Property tax$3,651 /yr
What it costs to own
Property tax$304 /mo
These are the listing’s recurring costs before any mortgage. Enter your own mortgage rate in the calculator below to estimate the monthly payment — we don’t assume a rate for you.
Excludes utilities, home insurance, repairs & upkeep, closing & financing-specific costs. Estimate only — not a loan offer or appraisal.
Description
Originally constructed in 1916 and thoughtfully transformed into a remarkable private residence, this one-of-a-kind church conversion offers nearly 3,800 square feet of finished living space while preserving the architectural character that makes it truly unforgettable. Approached through a timber-framed covered entrance, visitors are greeted by a dramatic two-storey stained glass window that hint...
My Notes
Saved in this browser only — notes are private to you and do not appear on your other devices.
I've toured this home
Property Details
Property TypeDetached
Style2-Storey
Size2500-3000 ft²
Days on Market13 days
MLS#X13752156
StatusActive
HeatingForced Air
A/CCentral Air
GarageNone
Parking Spaces2
BasementFull, Finished
OccupancyFlexible
Listed BySUTTON GROUP PREFERRED REALTY INC.
Tax Information
Annual Taxes$3,651
Tax Year2025
Room Details
| Room | Level | Size | Features |
|---|---|---|---|
| Living Room | Main | 4.394' × 3.505' | gas fireplace, hardwood floor |
| Den | Main | 3.175' × 2.311' | -- |
| Kitchen | Main | 4.851' × 3.912' | Hardwood Floor |
| Bedroom | Second | 3.226' × 2.362' | -- |
| Bedroom 3 | Lower | 3.658' × 3.073' | -- |
| Bedroom 2 | Second | 4.191' × 3.962' | -- |
| Other | Second | 4.394' × 4.166' | -- |
| Family Room | Main | 9.449' × 7.925' | Hardwood Floor |
| Dining Room | Main | 4.318' × 3.912' | Hardwood Floor |
| Primary Bedroom | Lower | 6.807' × 4.724' | walk-in closet(s), bamboo |
| Den | Second | 3.2' × 2.362' | -- |
| Bedroom | Main | 3.1' × 2.2' | -- |
| Game Room | Lower | 7.214' × 6.401' | -- |
| Laundry | Lower | 2.4' × 1.8' | -- |
Bathrooms
1 bathroom on Main (2 pieces)
1 bathroom on Second (3 pieces)
1 bathroom on Lower (5 pieces)
1 bathroom on Lower (2 pieces)
Amenities & Features
Nearby
GolfHospitalParkPlace Of WorshipPublic TransitSchool
Mortgage Calculator
$
%
%
Estimated Mortgage Payment
Enter your mortgage rate above to estimate a payment.
Estimate only — not a mortgage quote, pre-approval or lending offer. Term, interest rate and down payment are assumptions you can adjust. Below 20% down the figure includes CMHC/mortgage-default insurance, which lenders add to the mortgage. It excludes closing costs, utilities and other expenses, and does not reflect any specific lender. Confirm real numbers with a licensed mortgage professional.
Cash Flow Analysis
Mortgage Payment:—
Monthly Payment:—
Expense Ratio:—
Property Tax(Monthly):
$
Maintenance Cost:
$
Rental Income:
$
Down Payment:
%
Buying this as an investment?
Enter your expected monthly rent to model cash flow. If you plan to live here, you can skip this.* Source: Calculation formula is compiled by Homsy.ca. This is for educational use only.
Can you afford this home?
Enter your income and your own mortgage rate to check this home against a lender’s limits.
An estimate, not a pre-approval. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Market Statistics
Loading chart...
Unlock more property intelligence
Sold prices, price changes, and listing history are available to signed-in members under real-estate board (VOW) rules.
Sign in to view
Location
Similar listings
Listed : $729,000
2026-08-17
2 Evylean Court, St. Thomas
2
3
2
Listed : $359,900
2026-08-10
21 Isabel Street, St. Thomas
2
2